DfE's Plan to Scrap BREEAM in New Schools Sparks Whitehall Backlash

You are here: 

Quick Answer

The Department for Education (DfE) has proposed discontinuing the mandatory use of BREEAM, a prominent sustainability assessment method, for new school construction projects, which has generated considerable backlash across Whitehall. This controversial move is met with opposition because BREEAM is a recognized standard for ensuring high environmental performance in buildings, and its removal could compromise the sustainability and energy efficiency of future schools. Critics argue that abandoning BREEAM contradicts broader government commitments to achieving net-zero carbon emissions and environmental protection, potentially resulting in less accountable and lower-quality educational infrastructure.

The Department for Education has faced a growing industry backlash over the proposed plans to ditch BREEAM ratings and green standards in new school buildings. This has caused concern across Whitehall, with local government asking how abandoning BREEAM will assist with the agenda to become the greenest government yet.

The Department for Business, Innovation and Skills, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs and the Department for Energy and Climate Change are disputing the proposal. A source close to the situation said there were meetings going on across government with strong arguments being made on both sides.

Latest Posts

The 2027 Deadline: How to Future‑Proof Projects Starting in the Next 24 Months

Part L 2026 Explained: What the Future Homes Standard Means for Developers

Hillingdon Water Sports Facility

Hillingdon Water Sports Facility

Why New Builds Need Heat Pumps

What are the frequently asked questions regarding the DfE's BREEAM proposals in new schools?

1 What are the Department for Education's proposals regarding BREEAM in new schools?

The Department for Education (DfE) has proposed removing the requirement for BREEAM assessments in new school building projects. This move is part of an effort to streamline the design process and reduce costs. The proposals suggest replacing BREEAM with a new set of sustainability standards.

2 Why is there backlash against the DfE's plan to scrap BREEAM?

The backlash stems from concerns that scrapping BREEAM will lower environmental standards for new schools and hinder the UK's net-zero targets. Industry bodies, environmental groups, and even other government departments argue that BREEAM provides a robust framework for sustainable design and construction. Critics fear a loss of accountability and a decline in building quality.

3 What is BREEAM and why is it significant for school construction?

BREEAM (Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method) is a leading sustainability assessment method for masterplanning projects, infrastructure, and buildings. For school construction, it provides a comprehensive framework to measure and certify the environmental performance of buildings, covering aspects like energy, water, materials, and health. It ensures that new schools are built to high environmental and performance standards.

4 What are the potential implications of removing BREEAM for future school projects?

Removing BREEAM could lead to a reduction in the overall sustainability performance of new school buildings, potentially impacting energy efficiency, carbon emissions, and indoor environmental quality. It might also create uncertainty for developers and consultants accustomed to a clear, recognized standard. The article highlights concerns about the UK's ability to meet its climate goals without such a robust framework.